I-9 Compliance Audit Lawyer — Protecting Employers From ICE Inspections and Penalties

Every U.S. employer must complete Form I-9 for each new hire. Many employers have errors they do not know about. An I-9 compliance audit lawyer helps you find and fix those problems before an ICE inspection does.

I-9 penalties can add up quickly. Fines apply per form, so small mistakes across many employees become expensive. However, a careful internal audit can reduce risk significantly. Therefore, regular review is good business practice.

This guide explains I-9 basics, common mistakes, the inspection process and how to correct errors lawfully.

I-9 basics every employer must follow

Employees complete Section 1 no later than their first day of work. Employers complete Section 2 within three business days of the start date, after examining acceptable documents.

Employers must not specify which documents an employee presents. Doing so can be discriminatory. Furthermore, forms must be kept for three years after the hire date or one year after employment ends, whichever is later.

Remote verification

Employers enrolled in E-Verify may use an alternative remote document examination procedure, if they follow its requirements. Others must examine documents physically. Consequently, check which method you are allowed to use.

Common I-9 mistakes

Errors are common. Missing signatures, blank fields, late completion and incorrect document entries top the list. In addition, employers often forget to reverify expiring work authorization.

Over-documentation is another risk. Asking for more or different documents than required can lead to discrimination claims. Meanwhile, keeping copies of documents for some employees but not others can create problems too. A consistent compliance policy prevents this.

ICE Notices of Inspection

ICE begins an audit by serving a Notice of Inspection. Employers usually have three business days to produce their I-9s. That is not much time. Consequently, a well-organized file is essential.

After review, ICE may issue a notice of technical violations, which gives a chance to correct them. More serious violations can lead to fines. Knowingly employing unauthorized workers carries heavier penalties.

If you receive a notice, get advice immediately. An employer employment-law consultation reviews your response plan.

Correcting errors lawfully

When an audit finds mistakes, correct them properly. Never backdate a form. Instead, make corrections, initial and date them, and attach a short explanation where needed. For missing forms, complete a new I-9 with the current date.

Document your audit process. A memo explaining the review shows good faith. Furthermore, train staff who complete I-9s. Our employee handbook service can include onboarding procedures. For sponsored workers, see our guide to H-1B sponsorship.

Our I-9 Compliance services in the USA

Every service below has a fixed price, is prepared by a qualified attorney and is delivered online — wherever you are in the USA. Additionally, you can upload evidence, message your attorney and track progress from your secure client dashboard.

I-9 Compliance services near you — every state we cover

Because everything is handled online, it makes no difference where you live. Nevertheless, the law does change from state to state, so every document is prepared for your local rules. Here are some of the places our clients come from most often.

I-9 Compliance help in California

We prepare i-9 compliance documents for California law and local court practice. Clients come to us from Los Angeles (near the Stanley Mosk Courthouse downtown), San Diego (near the Hall of Justice on West Broadway), San Francisco (near the Civic Center courthouse on McAllister Street). For example, see Employer employment-law consultation in Los Angeles, Employer employment-law consultation in San Diego, Employer employment-law consultation in San Francisco. Similarly, see Compliance Policy & Procedure (per policy) in California.

I-9 Compliance help in Texas

We prepare i-9 compliance documents for Texas law and local court practice. Clients come to us from Houston (near the Harris County Civil Courthouse), Dallas (near the George L. Allen Sr. Courts Building), San Antonio (near the Bexar County Courthouse), Austin (near the Travis County Civil and Family Courts Facility). For example, see Employer employment-law consultation in Houston, Employer employment-law consultation in Dallas, Employer employment-law consultation in San Antonio, Employer employment-law consultation in Austin. Similarly, see Compliance Policy & Procedure (per policy) in Texas.

I-9 Compliance help in Florida

We prepare i-9 compliance documents for Florida law and local court practice. Clients come to us from Miami (near the Miami-Dade County Courthouse on West Flagler Street), Orlando (near the Orange County Courthouse), Tampa (near the George E. Edgecomb Courthouse). For example, see Employer employment-law consultation in Miami, Employer employment-law consultation in Orlando, Employer employment-law consultation in Tampa. Similarly, see Compliance Policy & Procedure (per policy) in Florida.

I-9 Compliance help in New York

We prepare i-9 compliance documents for New York law and local court practice. Clients come to us from New York City (near the New York County Courthouse at 60 Centre Street and the immigration court at 26 Federal Plaza), Brooklyn (near the Kings County Supreme Court on Adams Street). For example, see Employer employment-law consultation in New York City, Employer employment-law consultation in Brooklyn. Similarly, see Compliance Policy & Procedure (per policy) in New York.

I-9 Compliance help in Illinois

We prepare i-9 compliance documents for Illinois law and local court practice. Clients come to us from Chicago (near the Richard J. Daley Center). For example, see Employer employment-law consultation in Chicago. Similarly, see Compliance Policy & Procedure (per policy) in Illinois.

I-9 Compliance help in Georgia

We prepare i-9 compliance documents for Georgia law and local court practice. Clients come to us from Atlanta (near the Fulton County Courthouse). For example, see Employer employment-law consultation in Atlanta. Similarly, see Compliance Policy & Procedure (per policy) in Georgia.

I-9 Compliance help in Arizona

We prepare i-9 compliance documents for Arizona law and local court practice. Clients come to us from Phoenix (near the Maricopa County Superior Court). For example, see Employer employment-law consultation in Phoenix. Similarly, see Compliance Policy & Procedure (per policy) in Arizona.

I-9 Compliance help in Pennsylvania

We prepare i-9 compliance documents for Pennsylvania law and local court practice. Clients come to us from Philadelphia (near City Hall, home of the Court of Common Pleas). For example, see Employer employment-law consultation in Philadelphia. Similarly, see Compliance Policy & Procedure (per policy) in Pennsylvania.

I-9 Compliance help in Washington

We prepare i-9 compliance documents for Washington law and local court practice. Clients come to us from Seattle (near the King County Courthouse). For example, see Employer employment-law consultation in Seattle. Similarly, see Compliance Policy & Procedure (per policy) in Washington.

I-9 Compliance help in Colorado

We prepare i-9 compliance documents for Colorado law and local court practice. Clients come to us from Denver (near the Denver City and County Building). For example, see Employer employment-law consultation in Denver. Similarly, see Compliance Policy & Procedure (per policy) in Colorado.

I-9 Compliance help in Massachusetts

We prepare i-9 compliance documents for Massachusetts law and local court practice. Clients come to us from Boston (near the Edward W. Brooke Courthouse). For example, see Employer employment-law consultation in Boston. Similarly, see Compliance Policy & Procedure (per policy) in Massachusetts.

I-9 Compliance help in Nevada

We prepare i-9 compliance documents for Nevada law and local court practice. Clients come to us from Las Vegas (near the Regional Justice Center). For example, see Employer employment-law consultation in Las Vegas. Similarly, see Compliance Policy & Procedure (per policy) in Nevada.

I-9 Compliance help in New Jersey

We prepare i-9 compliance documents for New Jersey law and local court practice. Clients come to us from Newark (near the Essex County Hall of Records). For example, see Employer employment-law consultation in Newark. Similarly, see Compliance Policy & Procedure (per policy) in New Jersey.

I-9 Compliance help in North Carolina

We prepare i-9 compliance documents for North Carolina law and local court practice. Clients come to us from Charlotte (near the Mecklenburg County Courthouse). For example, see Employer employment-law consultation in Charlotte. Similarly, see Compliance Policy & Procedure (per policy) in North Carolina.

We also help clients in Alabama, Alaska, Arkansas, Connecticut, Delaware, District of Columbia, Hawaii, Idaho, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, New Hampshire, New Mexico, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, West Virginia, Wisconsin, Wyoming. See every location we cover.

Employer employment-law consultation in every state

Alabama · Alaska · Arizona · Arkansas · California · Colorado · Connecticut · Delaware · District of Columbia · Florida · Georgia · Hawaii · Idaho · Illinois · Indiana · Iowa · Kansas · Kentucky · Louisiana · Maine · Maryland · Massachusetts · Michigan · Minnesota · Mississippi · Missouri · Montana · Nebraska · Nevada · New Hampshire · New Jersey · New Mexico · New York · North Carolina · North Dakota · Ohio · Oklahoma · Oregon · Pennsylvania · Rhode Island · South Carolina · South Dakota · Tennessee · Texas · Utah · Vermont · Virginia · Washington · West Virginia · Wisconsin · Wyoming

Frequently asked questions

Contact American Counsel

Related guides

This guide is general information, not legal advice for your situation. Every case is different — speak to a qualified attorney before you act.